UPA’s last window of opportunity — Meet Indian Muslims' expectations

20 Actions Expected by Indian Muslims
We, the Indian Muslims, are extremely unhappy with the philosophy and agenda of the Sangh Parivar and hence will surely not vote for the BJP in the upcoming elections. However, this does not lead to the presumption that we will vote, a third time, for UPA. In 2004 the UPA came to power with massive Muslim support. It appointed Sachar Committee and Mishra Commission which submitted their reports which were accepted by the UPA Government. Muslims were happy and they again supported the UPA in 2009.

Problems of the Muslims have been documented in these two reports and their solutions have been identified after detailed discussions in and out of the government. But, during the last four years the UPA has been ignoring the implementation of major recommendations given in Sachar and Mishra reports despite systematic and frequent reminders given by the community and its well-wishers through media, conferences, presentations, memoranda and meetings with the prime minister and ministers.

Now the UPA has its last window of opportunity, July to December 2013, to pick up the threads, issue orders, give these in the hands of Muslims and their well-wishers and get these implemented at the ground level through intense follow up.

For UPA’s ready recapitulation following are the actions that it must take right now. Each of these actions have been pending for several years. After every item, in brackets, the ministry which has to take the action is mentioned. Muslims will take into account the UPA’s commissions & omissions at the hustings:

1. Create time-bound fast track courts to try terror allegations. (Ministries of Law and Home)

2. Provide compensation of Rs 50 lakh to each person who is judicially acquitted of terror allegations. Such amount elsewhere in the civilized world is much higher. (Home Ministry)

3. Make ‘Scheduled Caste’ definition religion-neutral. Amend 1950 Presidential Order through a simple parliamentary resolution. (Ministry of Law) or similar order by the President.

4. De-reserve constituencies with substantial Muslim population as recommended by the Sachar Committee. Immediately appoint the next Delimitation Commission with clear time-bound mandate to remove these anomalies. (Ministry of Law)

5. Evolve procedure to nominate Muslims in public positions of power. Mind you, post Sachar, Muslim representation in government has come further down. (Sachar Committee Report: Cabinet Secretariat & Ministry of Minority Affairs)

6.  Earmark 67% for Muslims out of the Reservation to be made for all minorities, as Muslims constitute 73% of all minorities. (Mishra Commission: Ministry of Law)

7. Create Special Component Plan in the Budget for Muslims for skill development programmes and other economic opportunities. (‘Promises to Keep’ by Harsh Mandar & others: Planning Commission & Ministry of Finance)

8. For the PM’s 15 Point Programme for Minorities, enhance the outlay to 19% of total plan allocation. (“Promises to Keep” by Harsh Mandar & others: Planning Commission & Ministry of Finance)

9. Make the village (in rural area) and ward (in urban area) [and not the district or block] as units of planning for infrastructure schemes (including Multi-sectoral Development Plan) and their implementation. (“Promises to Keep” by Harsh Mandar & others: Planning Commission & Ministry of Finance)

10. For special recruitment of 1400 additional IPS officers, scrap the Limited Competitive Examination (LCE) as it preempts Muslim intake. (Ministries of Personnel & Home)

11. Establish Indian Waqf Service on the pattern of several states where senior officers are directly recruited, by state law, to manage Hindu temples & endowments. (Sachar Report: Ministries of Personnel & Minority Affairs)

12. (a) In the Waqf Bill 2013, incorporate all the recommendations of Sachar Committee + Joint Parliamentary Committee on Waqfs. (Sachar Committee Report & JPC on Waqfs: Ministry of Minority Affairs) (b) Act on the then PM Indira Gandhi’s letter no. 71-PMO/76 dated March 26, 1976 addressed to the chief ministers - reproduced on page 223 of Sachar Committee Report. Vacate Waqf properties occupied by governments in the Centre and states and restore these to the state waqf boards. (Sachar Committee Report & JPC on Waqfs: PMO, Ministry of Minority Affairs, chief ministers)

13. Publicize Madrasa Scheme (SPQEM) in Urdu & other languages. Rs 50 lakh granted to the HRD Ministry every year for such publicity has not been utilized. (HRD Ministry)

14. Establish equivalence between Madarsa and other education. (Sachar Committee Report: Ministry of HRD, National Institute of Open Schooling and University Grants Commission]

15. Give option for interest-free finance in the banking sector. Implement the recommendations of the Planning Commission’s Raghuram Rajan Committee on financial sector reforms. (Planning Commission)

16. Central Urdu Teachers Scheme: Follow up and get resolved its non-implementation in most of the states. (Ministry of HRD)

17. Establish Equal Opportunity Commission. Modalities were finalized by the Expert Committee four years ago. (Sachar Committee Report: Ministry of Minority Affairs)

18. Institute the Schemes for Incentives based on Diversity Index. Modalities were finalized by Expert Committee four years ago. (Sachar Committee Report: Ministry of Minority Affairs)

19. Involve Muslim beneficiary groups in the planning & oversight of the schemes & projects aimed at their welfare. (Cabinet Secretariat & Ministry of Minority Affairs)

20. Concentrate on benefiting the whole Muslim community, not only a few individuals.

Detailed documentation on these issues, often obtained under Right to Information Act, is available with the Zakat Foundation of India.

If the current UPA Government continues its ‘mere lip-service’ policy towards Muslims even during its last six months, we need not vote for it a third time. Instead, we should begin putting our heads together for a non-UPA and non-BJP alternative.

A PowerPoint Presentation on this article can be seen at The author is

President, Zakat Foundation of India

This article appeared in The Milli Gazette print issue of 1-15 August 2013 on page no. 7

We hope you liked this report/article. The Milli Gazette is a free and independent readers-supported media organisation. To support it, please contribute generously. Click here or email us at

blog comments powered by Disqus